Column, 569 words

Leave No Generation Behind

A tax on inherited wealth could eliminate student debt while reducing growing inequality.

Chuck Collins

Over a decade ago, I got a call from Bill Gates.

Not the Bill Gates you’re probably thinking of. It was Bill Gates Sr., the Microsoft founder’s dad. He was eager to speak out in support of the federal estate tax, our nation’s only levy on inherited wealth.

He called it the “gratitude tax.” If you were fortunate enough to make millions, he believed, then you should “recycle your opportunity” for the next generation.

How might that work?

Bill Gates Sr. served in the Army in World War II. When he returned, the GI Bill enabled him to attend college and law school for free. His debt-free education propelled him to a career as an attorney and allowed him to provide excellent educational opportunities to his three children — one of whom is one of the two richest people on the planet.

Bill Gates, Sr.

Bill Gates, Sr. (jseattle/Flickr)

For today’s college-age youth, talk of a debt-free education sounds like science fiction. Over 40 million Americans owe student debt. The average student borrower graduated last year with $33,000 worth.

There’s no public benefit served by saddling the next generation with astronomical amounts of student debt. Research shows that student debt delays homeownership, discourages public service careers, and reduces entrepreneurial risk-taking.

Over the last three decades, staggering inequalities of income, wealth, and opportunity have emerged. As Federal Reserve Chairwoman Janet Yellen observed recently, the U.S. households in the bottom 50 percent lost half their net worth between 1989 and 2013, while the top 5 percent saw their net worth double.

This inequality is hitting the rising generation hard, as today’s students graduate into a much tougher job market than their parents did.

We need a GI Bill for the next generation. It would be a game changer for equality of opportunity.

That’s where the “gratitude tax” comes in.

Back in Washington State, Gates Sr. championed something called the Legacy Education Trust Fund — a dedicated education account capitalized by the state’s estate tax.

A similar fund at the national level — call it the Education Opportunity Recycling Fund — could provide debt-free or low-cost tuition for all American students, financed by revenue from the federal estate tax.

Access to funds could be linked to completion of two years of national service, either in the military or in community service programs such as AmeriCorps. The current benefits for both of these forms of national service are woefully insufficient to expand college opportunity.

The “recycling fund” would be the mechanism through which America’s millionaires and billionaires would pay back the society that made their wealth possible, thanks in part to public investments in education, infrastructure, property rights protections, and so much more.

The fund would have at least three major benefits.

First, it would boost college access while reducing student debt.

Second, it would put a brake on the growing concentration of wealth and power that’s corroding our democracy.

And finally, it would help reweave the social fabric of our communities, as young people in national service programs work side-by-side as teacher aides, elder care workers, and protectors of our natural areas.

The Greatest Generation after World War II was created not only by their own grit, but also through major public investments in their prosperity.

A similar investment is required for the next generation to rise to their full potential. Why should our greatest generation be behind us?

Chuck Collins is a senior scholar at the Institute for Policy Studies and the co-author, with Bill Gates Sr., of Wealth and Our Commonwealth: Why America Should Tax Accumulated Fortunes.
Distributed via

  • Elizabeth Whitehouse

    An excellent idea. I would go as far as taxing ALL unearned income – increase the capital gains tax, put a tax on stock exchange transactions (including cashing in stock options), and put a super sales tax on luxury items.