Column, 422 words

The Nuclear Industry’s Meltdown

The former chairman of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission says every single reactor in the nation should be shut down, starting with the riskiest.

ESG-by BC-1William A. Collins

The first thing to remember about nuclear power is that it’s not safe. Just ask Japan.

The second thing to remember is that nuclear power isn’t cheap. Connecticut draws half its juice from nuclear reactors and has the second-highest rates in the country, after Hawaii.

The third thing to know is that everybody lies about it. The power plant designers lie, the builders lie, the utility companies lie, the regulators lie, and the politicians lie.

ESGCollins-Nuclear-Free Grunge Textures

Free Grunge Textures –

Take Tokyo Electric Power Co. (TEPCO), the utility that ran the reactors in Japan’s Fukushima prefecture that failed after a tsunami and earthquake struck. TEPCO still won’t admit just how serious a disaster that was and continues to be.

But kids living downwind are already getting thyroid cancer, fish in the nearby sea are no longer safe to eat, and radioactive tuna are cruising the California coast. As with the Chernobyl disaster, tens of thousands of people may never be free to return home.

Meanwhile at many U.S. nuclear reactors, efficiency is declining and the risk of accidents is rising. Unlike at a coal-fired power plant, you can’t just hit the off switch if there’s a flood, drought, or power failure. All those spent nuclear fuel rods have to be cooled for years to come, whether you have water handy or not.

In Connecticut, Dominion Resources is seeking permission to keep pumping water from Long Island Sound, even when global warming has heated that body up beyond the temperature allowed by federal regulations.

Still not worried? Consider this: Former Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Chairman Gregory B. Jaczko declared in April that he believes every single nuclear power plant operating in the nation should be shut down, starting with the riskiest.

This isn’t completely far-fetched. So far this year, power companies have announced plans to close five reactors. Most recently, Entergy relented on its mission to keep its creaky Yankee nuclear plant in Vermont operational over the state government’s clear objections.

At least 37 more reactor closures could follow, according to Mark Cooper, a senior fellow for economic analysis at Vermont Law School’s Institute for Energy and the Environment.

Can environmentalists celebrate this nuclear downsizing trend?

Nope. Most experts aren’t attributing this rash of reactor closures to any newfound safety concerns among the industry’s leaders. Instead, they’re blaming the fracking boom.

As it devastates the environment, cheap fracked gas is sapping demand for nuclear reactors and coal-fired power plants.

Emily Schwartz Greco is the managing editor of OtherWords, a non-profit national editorial service run by the Institute for Policy Studies. OtherWords columnist William A. Collins is a former state representative and a former mayor of Norwalk, Connecticut.

  • Johnny Dollar

    Is someone supposed to learn something from this article? From what I gather, coal is now politically correct again. Suits me fine. We have plenty of that as well as natural gas. Let’s burn it up and produce electricity. That’s what it’s there to do. Can’t produce goods without electricity.

    What I don’t understand is the complaints against nuclear power. Some say there’s something called global warming and some of it is caused by burning coal. I read the oceans are rising because of it. Seems to me the perfect solution is to line all coasts with nuclear power plants. They can take in all that nasty rising water and vaporize it in the cooling process. What could be a simpler solution?

    • ESGreco

      “Johnny”: You can learn from this short article that there are many downsides to nuclear energy but that fracking is what at long last is shutting down reactors across the country.

      Jim: Commentaries are a vehicle for participating in the broader debate. You can look elsewhere for a different perspective. I disagree with your characterization of this column as a “rant.” And you should look for more nuclear reactor closures to follow as long as natural gas prices remain this low and the situation in Fukushima only grows more dire.

      • Johnny Dollar

        Good. I’m currently invested in natural gas. I hope the price doubles or triples when the reactors are shut down. Let’s stop all new fracking. There’s nothing better to drive up the price than cut off the growth of supply. I’ll support anything you want that increases my account balances. I don’t live anywhere near the seashore anyway.

  • Jim

    Would love to hear some real debate, rather than one sided rant. Could you get the makers of Pandoras Promise on the stage to debate ? It’s required viewing for anyone who want to hear both sides.