Almost nobody expects jail time for failure to pay a parking ticket or highway toll, right?
But in most U.S. cities, public transit riders can be charged with a misdemeanor for failure to pay the full fare. The punishment for “fare evasion” is on par with that of property theft, driving under the influence, or assault.
But jumping a turnstile isn’t criminal, and it shouldn’t be treated like it is.
This criminalization of fare evasion has caused an unnecessary and terrorizing police presence on public transit. A black 17-year-old who jumped a turnstile in New York was beaten by police and later died from the injuries. In Minneapolis, a 23-year-old’s arrest for evading a $1.75 fare led to his deportation.
Akshai Singh, an organizer at Clevelanders for Public Transit in Ohio, said that “if you ask riders or operators if transit police make them feel safer, they laugh.”
Police have no business being on public transportation. Two of the key drivers of fare evasion are inconvenient or broken fare collection systems and poverty — neither of which can be addressed by police.
Many public transportation riders don’t have the cash to pay for a ride to work or school. They evade out of necessity.
Since fare evaders overwhelmingly don’t have the cash to afford a $2 fare, they certainly can’t pay a citation worth hundreds of dollars. And failure to pay a citation means jail time. In Minnesota, less than 3 percent of fare evaders are able to pay their fines.
When enforcing these harsh punishments, police directly target riders who are poor, Black, or both.
In New York, the frequency of enforcement in high-poverty neighborhoods is more than twice that in other neighborhoods, and Black riders are 30 times more likely to be arrested for evasion than white riders. In Washington, D.C., 91 percent of citations for fare evasion between 2016 and 2019 were issued to Black riders.
In other words, the criminalization of fare evasion means more Black people face police brutality and the criminal justice system for harmless infractions.
And it’s not just the riders that this criminalization threatens — it’s also the operators and bus drivers who are forced to report alleged evaders to the cops. A significant chunk of violence toward drivers and operators occurs at the ticket box, so eliminating the threat of a misdemeanor would reduce escalation and therefore protect drivers and operators.
With increasing calls for defunding police, decriminalizing fare evasion is a no-brainer.
There is no evidence that lighter penalties for evasion lead to revenue loss for transit areas, but there is overwhelming evidence that criminal penalties for fare evasion make transit risky for riders and operators.
San Francisco, D.C., Seattle, and Portland have recently decriminalized fare evasion. Every city should follow.
And that’s just the first step. Eliminating the fare entirely would promote mobility as a human right. It even makes economic sense in cities like New York, which is currently spending $249 million on new cops to save $200 million on fare evasion.
At worst, punishment for fare evasion should be treated like failure to pay a parking ticket or highway toll. Anything more is criminalizing poverty and endangering riders and operators.
OtherWords commentaries are free to re-publish in print and online — all it takes is a simple attribution to OtherWords.org. To get a roundup of our work each Wednesday, sign up for our free weekly newsletter here.